In today’s candidate-driven market, attracting the right GTM talent to your startup is critical for growth. The challenge is doing it consistently in competitive hiring environments.
Many agencies talk about the challenge of finding passive candidates for SaaS sales roles.
In other words, high-performing candidates who are not actively looking, but will engage when the right opportunity is presented.
It might be logical, therefore, to leave this in the hands of your internal recruiter who with a well-placed advert and LinkedIn campaign will attract the exact candidate you are looking for; wouldn’t it?
Unfortunately, this isn’t always the case.
Key Points
- A poor candidate experience harms your startup’s ability to attract and secure top SaaS sales talent.
- The best candidate journeys combine clear expectations, structured processes, and timely feedback.
- Internal recruitment teams often lack the time to provide consistent communication and coaching.
- Specialist search consultancies add value by tailoring screening, advising candidates, and protecting your employer brand.
- Every touchpoint matters: strong communication and transparency build trust and reputation in the market.
The All-Important Candidate Experience
The challenge is an in-house recruitment team is under huge pressure to advertise every single role, follow up on referrals, and find that needle in the haystack. All whilst in theory giving a good impression to the candidates about the organisation, they are applying to – and also on a tight time deadline.
This becomes even more important when entering new markets, where your brand is less established and candidates rely heavily on the experience you create during the hiring process.
Picture this scenario: a SaaS company expanding into a new market. Well known in the US, but relatively unknown in Europe, or vice versa. An attractive, branded advert is commissioned, with receiving over 300 applications. All great PR, in theory, until you consider the candidate experience.
The downside is the role is specialist. The likelihood is the majority of candidates are rejected upon application or after a first interview when, unfortunately, the initial ‘hype’ has done its job in making them emotionally invested in working for that company.
The standard ‘no thanks’ email does or doesn’t get sent (often the latter), and the impression of the new ‘brand’ literally goes down the toilet.
This isn’t an exaggeration. According to Glassdoor, 72% of candidates who had a poor experience will share it online. Whether it’s conversations with peers, colleagues, or within their network, candidates share these experiences quickly. Negative encounters, in particular, tend to get passed along as warnings about ‘poor’ organisations.
“If you do build a great experience, customers tell each other about that. Word of mouth is very powerful. But keep in mind that a customer who has a bad experience is likely to tell 6–7 people, whereas a customer who has a good experience tells maybe 3-4.”
– Jeff Bezos, Amazon
What Does Make a Good Candidate Experience?
The truth? Attention to detail and a process. This is where using the skills of a specialist recruitment partner aligned to your sector comes in. Either working specifically for an organisation or working hand in hand with your internal recruitment function.
When this happens, the majority of the potential pitfalls listed above can be avoided.
A specialist agency has the luxury of picking battles as it’s less of a volume based game and one in which they have significant experience.
A classic example is screening. A key advantage of the candidate not knowing who the hiring company is until mutual interest in progressing to a more in depth discussion has been established, makes for a totally different experience.
Above is a screenshot from the Teem LinkedIn account in response to an individual who had applied for a specific role we were recruiting for. A timely response from ourselves made all the difference to this one individual, whilst at the same time maintaining the integrity of the organisation we were recruiting for.
Which leads me onto what specifically contributes to a great candidate experience.
Coaching Through the Process
An important aspect that many general recruitment agencies forget.
There is now a whole global industry that has sprung up to help people develop their careers. Though who better placed to do this than an experienced search consultant? A conversation with a prospective candidate about their career goals and aspirations can save everyone time, money and disappointment.
Commitment
Commitment to the whole process is vital if you want a candidate to be totally bought into your startup opportunity. Time is a huge factor, and this is where your preferred search partner will add value to the delivery of your recruitment process. Internal recruiters often don’t have enough hours in the day to keep everyone in the loop, happy and informed.
Positioning, Expectation and Over Promising
There is a saying that ‘the truth hurts’. I disagree, truth hurts when it’s either not delivered or communicated far too late in the process. One of the reasons we have continued to be successful at Teem is the fact that we tell the truth and set expectations about what may or may not happen for both our candidates and clients.
Tailoring Applications and CVs
Over that last 18+ years, we have helped many A-players tailor their application and CV. All too often, experienced pros don’t appreciate that their past experience in a specific area or project is exactly what the client is looking for. Or even have their metrics clearly stated!
Even great sales people can undersell themselves. Click here if you need some more insight on this.
Communication Skills
An obvious point, but communication happens at many levels, from active listening to what the candidate and client really want, through to the common decency of staying in contact throughout the process. Especially if the news isn’t as good as the candidate or client was originally hoping for!
Professional candidates want constructive feedback because that way they can do something about it. In many cases, your search consultant is best placed to deliver this as a professional and experienced ‘go between’.
A strong candidate experience directly reflects your company and influences whether top GTM talent chooses to engage with your opportunity. With a structured process and consistent communication, you increase your chances of securing A-players while protecting your reputation in the market.




